Skip to main content

American Cheese

American cheesemaking has made huge headway in the past few decades, offering local dairy cheeses that are so darn delicious they even stand up to the time-honored classics of Europe. The mixture of old and new, the marriage of the cheesemaking secrets of European immigrants with that enviable American spirit for innovation has produced the very best expression of American cheese.

At Gourmet Food Store you can buy a wide selection of top quality American cheese online, including delicious chevres from Vermont Creamery and Cypress Grove, innovative cheddars from California-based Fiscalini, and our exclusive Italian-style mozzarellas and burratas made fresh to order by Mamma's Cheese in Miami. Plenty of choices of cheer-inducing cheeses made right here within our own shores!
Name
Milk Type
Texture
Type
Origin
Shape
Price
Availability
1 - 28 of 120 products
2 3 4 5  Next
1 - 28 of 120 products
2 3 4 5  Next
Fresh Stracciatella with Truffles
Fresh Stracciatella with Truffles
from United States by Mamma’s Cheese

Stretchy shreds of creamy Italian-style cheese peppered with black truffle for added decadence.

5(5 reviews)
Fresh Mozzarella Ovolini
Fresh Mozzarella Ovolini
from United States by Mamma’s Cheese

Mild, soft mozzarella with an oval shape and porcelain-like smoothness, made fresh to order

5(4 reviews)
Maytag Blue
Maytag Blue
from United States by Maytag

A piquant American blue cheese produced by hand in Iowa since 1941.

5(3 reviews)
Mozzarella Treccione
Fresh Mozzarella Treccione
from United States by Mamma’s Cheese

Mild and soft-texturedmozzarella hand-spun into an elegant braid shape, great by itself or with accompaniments

5(3 reviews)
Fiscalini 18 Month Farmstead Cheddar
Fiscalini 18 Month Farmstead Cheddar
from United States by Fiscalini Farm

A delicious extra mature cheddar cheese from California.

5(3 reviews)
Fresh Stracciatella
Fresh Stracciatella
from United States by Mamma’s Cheese

Made in Miami the Italian way, this cow's milk cheese is lusciously creamy and soft with salty notes.

4.9(16 reviews)
Fresh Smoked Mozzarella
Fresh Smoked Mozzarella
from United States by Mamma’s Cheese

Fresh smoked mozzarella made from scratch in an Italian market, smoked to enhance its natural flavor

4.9(8 reviews)
Fresh Mozzarella - Fior Di Latte
Fresh Mozzarella - Fior Di Latte
from United States by Mamma’s Cheese

With a name meaning "milk's flower," this cow's milk mozzarella has a spongy texture and fresh, creamy taste

4.7(11 reviews)
Burrata Cheese
Fresh Burrata Cheese
from United States by Mamma’s Cheese

Specially ordered for the utmost freshness, this soft mozzarella pouch oozes with rich creamy goodness

4.7(18 reviews)
Truffle Burrata
Fresh Truffle Burrata
from United States by Mamma’s Cheese

An ultra-fresh mozzarella casing conceals truffle-infused cream that gushes out when you slice in half

4.7(17 reviews)
Smoked Gouda
Smoked Gouda
from Netherlands by Taste Holland

A flavorful robust smoked version of the world-famous Gouda.

4.7(3 reviews)
Fresh Mozzarella - Nodini
Fresh Mozzarella Nodini
from United States by Mamma’s Cheese

Knot-shaped, rindless mozzarella with spongy, semi-soft texture and mild flavor, delivered fresh to your door

4.7(3 reviews)
Prairie Breeze Cheddar- Precut
Prairie Breeze Cheddar- Precut
from United States by Milton Creamery

This six time award winner Prairie Breeze aged white cheddar is crumbly yet creamy with a savory finish you’ll love.

Corner Stone - Raw Cow Milk Cheese
Corner Stone - Raw Cow Milk Cheese
from United States by Parish Hill Creamery

A new American classic, Corner Stone is a collaboration between three farms to explore the power of terroir.

Cabot Clothbound
Cabot Clothbound
from United States by Cellars at Jasper Hill

A traditional Vermont cheddar with wonderful notes of caramel and milk.

San Joaquin Gold
San Joaquin Gold
from United States by Fiscalini

A firm cheddar-like cheese with mild, sweet flavor and nutty aroma, great for snacking, grating and melting.

5(4 reviews)
This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Bonne Bouche
Bonne Bouche
from United States by Vermont Creamery

A sublimely runny, creamy and delicious little ash-ripened chevre from Vermont.

5(2 reviews)
This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Fiscalini Purple Moon - Wine Soaked Cheddar
Purple Moon - Wine Soaked Cheddar
from United States by Fiscalini

A delightful purple-rinded cheddar that's been soaked in a Californian Cabernet for a unique, fruity finish

5(1 review)
This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Monterey Jack, Dry - Aged 10 Months
Monterey Jack - Aged 10 Months
from United States by Vella Cheese

A classic American cheese, dry-aged 10 months for a firm, straw-hued paste and sweet nutty flavor.

5(1 review)
This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Fiscalini Hopscotch Cheddar - Scotch Ale Beer Cheddar
Hopscotch Cheddar - Scotch Ale Beer Cheddar
from United States by Fiscalini

Soaked in beer, this malty, hop-spiked cheddar is great for casual night snacking, dips, burgers and more.

4(1 review)
This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Provolone Cheese Slices
Provolone Cheese Slices
from United States by Great Lakes Cheese

One of Americas' most beloved sandwich cheeses, this Provolone is mild, delicious and convenient!

3(1 review)
This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Gorgonzola Cheese
Gorgonzola Cheese
from United States by Wisconsin Gold

Creamy-crumbly blue-veined Gorgonzola, made with farm-fresh ingredients and aged for over 90 days

This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Burrata alla Panna
Burrata alla Panna
from United States by Di Stefano

Presented in green-tied bag, this mozzarella hides Italian cream and stracciatella in its center

This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Humboldt Fog - Pre order -
Humboldt Fog (pre-order)
from United States by Cypress Grove

Made by Cypress Grove Chevre in California's Humboldt County, this beautiful goat cheese is creamy and buttery.

This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Gouda Cheese
Gouda Cheese
from United States by Wisconsin Gold

A buttery-flavored Gouda with firm yet creamy texture, made within our own shores

This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Fiscalini Smoked Cheddar
Smoked Cheddar
from United States by Fiscalini

A caramel-hued cheddar smoked over local apple, cherry and hickory wood chips for a rustic, woodsy flavor.

This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Fresh Goat Cheese
Fresh Goat Cheese
from United States by MontChevre

Known for its clean and tangy flavor, made from prime quality goat's milk of Wisconsin and Iowa.

This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
Grafton Clothbound Cheddar
Clothbound Cheddar
from United States by Grafton

A cheddar-like cheese from the Auverge region, with a mildly sharp taste and smooth texture.

This product is currently out of stock. Request a Back In Stock Notification.
1 - 28 of 120 products
2 3 4 5  Next

American Cheese Questions And Answers

visit our family of brands
Steaks And Game
For steak and meat lovers.
Gourmet Food World
The chef's ingredient marketplace.